All articles

Jamaica: debt, development and the IMF

Completing the IMF programme did not mean Jamaica had repaid the Fund. How the country got there, what is still owed, and what must come next for growth.

Is Jamaica done with the IMF?

The headlines that Jamaica is set to complete the latest Stand-by arrangement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in 2019 has been interpreted by many that Jamaica has paid off all its debts to the Fund. However, this is not so; as of the end of August 2019 Jamaica has $494 million USD in liabilities owed to the IMF.

Why did Jamaica engage the IMF again?

Jamaica’s NIR entered a downward trajectory in 2011, gradually falling from more than $2.5 billion US in March 2011 to less than $900 million by March 2013. At that time, Jamaica’s NIR was considered unsustainable as it could only buy less than the bench mark 12 weeks of imports. With a debt ratio of over 140 percent of GDP at the time, Jamaica for two years found it difficult to access funds from the international lending market. The country was given a lifeline when the IMF signed an Extended Fund Facility (EFF) agreement in 2013 which provided a seal of approval.

What did the EFF do?

This Extended Fund Facility made approximately $932 million USD available to Jamaica for four years through disbursements base on the country’s ability to pass quarterly review tests. Throughout that time Jamaica also embarked on two debt swops, a JDX and a NDX that allowed longer maturity period and lower rates of interest on some of the country’s loans. Jamaica also had to maintain a primary surplus of 7.5 percent of GDP which it did throughout the time of the agreement. The government implemented a fiscal rule that was essential in guiding the proper use of government funds. The EFF ended in 2016 and was replaced by the Standby Agreement that made $1.6 billion available on standby. Today Jamaica’s NIR is at $3.7US billion it can buy 32 weeks of goods and 22 weeks of goods and services.

What is the value of Jamaica’s debt now?

Since the inception of the Extended Fund Facility in 2013, Jamaica embarked on a series of policy reforms directed towards debt reduction. The countries debt in percentage terms fell from more than 140 percent of GDP to less than 100 percent of GDP currently and more restructuring is being done to reduce the debt percentages. The Ministry of Finance have outline in the supplementary budget the instead of 37% of this year’s budget will go towards debt serving 2% more than the 35% tabled at the beginning of the year. Jamaica owes more than $1.8 trillion JMD dollars in liabilities to its creditors and continues to struggle with its growth and development pursuits.

The 5 in 4 promise was an illusion

In 2016 the government hypothesized that their policies could put Jamaica on an upward growth trajectory reaching real GDP growth of 5% by 2020. To date, Jamaica continues to grow by less than two percent per annum and regressing further away from the 5% target. Sometimes GDP growth can be mistaken to be merely just a number derived from instinct; therefore any arbitrary group can suggest a 5% growth projection without a clear plan of action as to how the country will do so. Bear in mind that Jamaica has grown by an average of 0.7 percent since independence. I would not want us to believe that it’s a lack of effort rather than know how why the country cannot grow to develop how it wants to.

How does growth occur?

GDP should be seen as a group of output activities that span different industries, laterally and vertically. The interconnectedness of the various industries and the possibility of the potential growth in each sector should be analysed using cost benefit analysis, swot analysis accompanied by sensitivity and contingency analysis in case of any unfavourable occurrences. The aim should be to create a thorough output plan for the country mapping the industries that have the most potential based on calculated productivity outcome through processes, linkages and procedures to select the industries that are pursued.

What can the government do?

Fiscal policy has a huge role to play. Any subsidies and leverage that exist in the budget should be directed towards value added driven industries and productive activity. Last year the government created leverage in the budget and reallocated it to transfer taxes that gave advantage to those purchasing property. This leverage could easily be directed towards producers who vertically diversify products, or those creating renewable energy, or those making technologically driven products and processes. That leverage could even be used to invest in proper sustainable water harvesting and distribution facilities so that agricultural output stabilized and does not decline in the summer time as it has been doing over the last couple of years. We have to think carefully about the outcome before participate in a particular activity. Or do we care about the outcome?

This article was published in The Gleaner.

Find it in The Gleaner’s archive

Join the discussion

Tell me what you think. Comments are moderated, so keep it respectful.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join the discussion