All articles

Inflation targeting will not work in Jamaica

Evidence that inflation targeting can lower growth, and why a small, import-dependent economy has too much to lose from relying on it alone.

Mishkin (2001) has found evidence to suggest that Inflation Targeting has the potential to lower economic growth and since it is the government objective to increase economic growth, then practicing Inflation Targeting might be counter-intuitive. Even though the objective of inflation targeting is to attempt to stabilize prices in an attempt to increase output; it might end up doing the opposite. It turns out that the disadvantages of inflation targeting far outweigh the advantages.

No capacity to predict time inconsistencies.

A serious problem for Central banks in developing and emerging market economies is the ability to accurately predict the lag effect of the monetary policy instrument. The Central bank must possess the capacity to accurately predict the length of time between the day of the announcement and the time the actual forecast comes into effect. The BOJ for example outlined a medium term target to be achieved over a year or two but tried to publicly justify why they failed to achieve the target in three months, a quarterly target. This too is counterintuitive since the premise of inflation targeting is not to focus on the short run but on medium term targets. This means that quarterly deviations from actual inflation rates are allowable.

Weak Central Bank Capacity

Davis and Fujiwara (2015) shows that countries with a weak institutional framework might find it difficult to pre determine a particular inflation rate and therefore be unable to forecast output growth. The Central Bank Governors in most, if not all of the less than 30 countries that practice inflation targeting are published reputable PhD’s in International Finance or related field and their supporting staff are experts in macroeconomic modelling and forecasting. This gives them an advantage in their decision making process and therefore their ability to accurately attempt to target inflation. Jamaica, on the other hand does not possess this institutional capacity at its Central Bank and therefore might not be able to target inflation accurately.

Central Banks loses credibility

Mishkin (2001) explains that central banks can lose credibility by attempting to predict the inflation rate but failing to achieve that target at the appointed time. An increase in price prediction inaccuracy reduces the manufacturers or the service providers’ ability to predict input prices; indecisiveness increases friction that might have a negative effect on production levels and hence reduces GDP. Inflation targeting might correspond to extreme exchange rate flexibility that might cause financial instability and lead to further output volatility.

The Net interest rate differential

Central Banks must also have a thorough understanding of the net interest rate differential between them and other trading partners. If the US Federal reserve for example, increases interest rates to attract capital and the Bank of Jamaica reduces interest rates to detract capital, what would be the resulting effect on the exchange rate? I guess if there is an increase the net interest rate position of the US relative to the Jamaican then people will demand more US investment and therefore demand more US dollars causing the Jamaican exchange to depreciate. This would make a reasonable practical exam question for my macroeconomics class. If Jamaica focuses too much on domestic issues trying to lower the policy interest rate in a stubborn monetary transmission mechanism with lagged incomplete response from the market lending rate, while ignoring the net interest rate differential, what would be the resulting effect on the exchange rate? A central bank that understands International Finance must make the necessary alignment to prevent any capital flight or misalignment which inflation targeting does not permit. The financial system should be administered cognisant of international financial developments that might jeopardize the effectiveness of domestic monetary policy.

I ability to respond to shocks

A Major criticism of inflation targeting is that reduces the Central Banks ability to respond to and accommodate external shocks. Inflation targeting therefore limits the flexibility of the central banks which Jamaica cannot afford given the small open economy that we operate, we must be able to use monetary policy to accommodate shocks that might impact us negatively.

Lack of flexibility

Due to is several disadvantages, majority of the countries in the world (More than 170 countries) do not practice inflation Targeting. Instead, they rightly continue to use monetary policy to complement fiscal policy to balance the interaction between the goods and the money market. Monetary policy is employed therefore to achieve multiple objectives at the same time. Jamaica as country that does not have fiscal space to effectively stimulate the economy must have the flexibility to employ monetary policy to achieve equilibrium between the goods and the money market in real life, not in theory. If not accountable to the government, then to whom, the invisible hand?

This article was published in The Gleaner.

Find it in The Gleaner’s archive

Join the discussion

Tell me what you think. Comments are moderated, so keep it respectful.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join the discussion