What is causing the crisis?
The Coronavirus has been spreading rapidly across the world. The World Health Organisation (WHO) has declared the virus a pandemic and governments have issued disaster type warnings. Restrictions have been placed on public gatherings, school and many business places are closed for at least the next two weeks across the island. Two villages have been entirely quarantined and there has been limited movement and transportation of goods, services and people. The resulting negative economic impact is projected to be severe and an economic crisis appears to be certain.
What do economists recommend?
Some economists around the world have been calling for their governments to intervene to boost consumer demand in this economic slowdown. However, the coronavirus has instigated a negative shock to the supply of goods and services worldwide leading to a type of supply crisis. In this case, where people have money but nothing to spend it on, it might leads to inflation. Many people are ill and/or susceptible to being ill and as a result, can’t work hence a slowdown in supply. Any policy geared towards increasing demand without a corresponding effort to increase supply can cause stagflation; a period falling economic output and high prices.
What about Jamaica?
The Jamaican government in particular have outlined a reduction in general consumption tax (GCT) as of the April, 2020 in an effort to boost overall demand. This policy though might have been thought through before the crisis, should have adjusted to suit crisis conditions especially given its severity. Fiscal policy although planned based on a budget cycle should be flexible to alter with a change in economic conditions at any given time, it cannot be stiff and rigid. The reduction in GCT might prove to be a counterintuitive policy given that the coronavirus is a negative shock to supply. The fall in supply is as a result of slowdown in business activity across the world, many people are not at work so many people not producing. Over the medium term if there is no increase in supply, fall in taxes might just lead to an increase in imports once more. Government policy should therefore be geared towards increasing or stabilizing supply.
What about the central bank?
Some might be looking to the Central Bank to solve this crisis. However this is not a monetary policy issue. The world economy is fairly liquid, interest rates are very low. In this time, policy easing geared towards injecting more money in the economy might not have the desired effect now. The central bank’s indicator rate is already at 0.5%, any lower will be close to zero or negative interest rates that will reduce the central bank’s ability to respond to any monetary phenomenon that might arise.
What should be the focus?
The focus right now should be minimizing the negative impact of the crisis on businesses and citizens. Firms must at this time waver fees, penalties and charges on many goods and services. Land lords should forego rent and utility companies forego utility bills. The government must put measures in place to provide some type of unemployment and underemployment insurance to provide income to those who cannot work because of the crisis. No one should lose their pay because they cannot work during this time. The government should deliberate tax relief for firms who compensate employees fairly or who lose out due to the crisis. The easing must be directed towards to productive sector. There should be supply driven tax reliefs to boost the productive sector over the medium term.
How will Jamaica cope?
Countries including Jamaica must strategize to increase domestic production. In light of the crisis, instead of a slight marginal reduction in GCT, there should be a significant decline on Special Consumption Tax on Petrol, Petroleum products, Heavy Fuel Oil and similar products, which are necessary input in the production process. This would deliberately reduce the cost of production of everything domestic as well as reduce consume expenditure on everything that uses energy to produce. It would be giving a tax waiver to domestically produced goods. This would reduce the cost of services and transportation thereby putting the government on an upward growth trajectory. Lowering the cost of energy is a supply side policy that could reduce costs across the board; manufacturing goods & services (restaurants, hairdressing, barber, taxi, goods transportation and logistics, BPO’s and technology usage), while researching alternative energy.
Join the discussion
Tell me what you think. Comments are moderated, so keep it respectful.