All articles

Fiscal policies and national development

With income inequality high and average earnings low, why Jamaica’s fiscal policy should be directed at putting the country on a stable development path.

Expansionary fiscal policy either through a reduction in taxes or an increase in government spending is normally geared towards increasing economic activity, GDP growth and economic development. Often times there are competing ideas as to the policy options that are best in each point in time throughout history. The 2019 Human Development Report has indicated that income inequality is very high in Jamaica. Note that the average income in Jamaica is roughly $600,000 JMD per year or $50,000 per month, with a large percentage of the population earning below this amount. In this regard, Jamaica should expel all its fiscal efforts towards putting the country on a stable development path which would increase average income straight across the board to the benefit of everyone. The focus therefore should be on economic development and wealth creation instead of economic growth and job creation.

A tax cut has a multiplier effect in an ideal world

A tax cut is expected to have a multiplier effect on the overall economy based on standard macroeconomic theory. GDP should increase by the amount of the tax multiplier that is based on how much people save or consume. Last Fiscal Year the current government embarked on an expansionary fiscal policy by reducing taxes by roughly $14 billion. Let us assume that the average Jamaica consumes 80% of their income then a simple tax multiplier is 4 so that output should expand by 4 times the $14 billion tax cut or $56 billion JMD. This should have been translated into a 3 percent increase in economic growth based on the multiplier effect but this rate of growth has not been forthcoming. As a matter of fact, GDP is expected to grow by the usual 1% or less without any impetuous being generated from the expansionary policy. A tax cut of $25 billion should under ideal circumstances be reflected in a $100 billion JMD ($714 million USD) using the same multiplier effect, which would equate to 5% GDP growth assuming that GDP is currently $15 billion US. This could be achieved in an ideal world, but Jamaica is far from ideal. For example,

How to mobilize the economy

Assuming the economy is like a vehicle, such a misalignment in fuel injection (lower taxes) to the speed of output (increase GDP) would imply that it is not about how much fuel goes into the engine but rather the size of the engine that determines how fast the vehicle goes (how fast economy grows). As a result, rather than injecting more gas (tax cut) into a small engine and the vehicle stalls (little economic growth), it might be more relevant for the engineers to focus increasing the size of the engine if they want the vehicle to go faster. Using the same example, it might be more important for economists to change their focus. Instead of expanding fiscal policy in pursuit of direct economic growth, fiscal policy should be directed towards increasing the capacity of the economy through the process of economic development.

Jamaica’s economics is far from ideal

Jamaica is far from ideal, operating in an open economy with international trade a large percentage of excess spending goes towards more imports, so the open economy multiplier is much less. The government spending multiplier is greater than the tax multiplier, which would signal that a larger economic return is to be has from direct government spending rather than lowering taxes. Furthermore Jamaica has more innate handicaps that are far more in need of fiscal attention. First, Jamaica has to pay attention to its production and productivity issues. Poor harvesting and distribution of a basic necessity such as water has been having a negative effect on output in rural areas and standards of living everywhere. Any excess fiscal space generated from the country’s fiscal should be directed towards creating water catchments for all communities in all parishes ASAP. GIS mapping of all the water sources can be used to orchestrate the proper distribution of water throughout rural and urban communities across the island.

A quest towards economic development

Young people need genuine avenue to properly enterprise themselves. Jamaica needs a Technology and innovation enhancement fund. The special economic zones policies should be geared towards creating value added along these lines. The health care system is deplorable and our nurses are not properly compensated for the work they do, the crime situation is very bad and the police are demotivated because they lack adequate compensation, teachers and other civil servants are also unhappy. A portion of this amount must be geared towards improving these sectors and the compensations packages they receive. Always remember that the quality of the civil services determines the quality of the country. If civil services are poorly distributed then the country is in problems. Jamaica faces severe healthcare issues, and some of this money saved by government should be geared towards improving health care. Waste disposal and waste management is also major issue.

GIS mapping is now the new trends, spatial maps for cities, towns and rural areas, these maps illustrate different layers required for the country to function effectively and give us a way to check and balance the country’s progress. Research and development as well as government policies must be geared towards meeting the world where it is by leapfrogging the present through the use of data, block chain technology, and Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Robotics It is our intention to move from smart communities, to smart divisions, to smart constituencies, to smart cities to a smart country… The use of Block chain technology can solve many of our problems including government inefficiencies.

Please do not forget to put my info

This article was published in The Gleaner.

Find it in The Gleaner’s archive

Join the discussion

Tell me what you think. Comments are moderated, so keep it respectful.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join the discussion